Man Gets 6 Months For Torturing Girlfriend’s Cat To Death

A 24-year-old man dunked a cat in cold water then beat it with his fist. It died hours later. Is six months a justified sentence?

Credit: Champaign County Sheriff's Office

Credit: Champaign County Sheriff’s Office

In central Illinois, a man was recently sentenced to six months in jail and probation for torturing his girlfriend’s cat, which later died.

According to the (Champaign) News-Gazette, the 24-year-old abuser, Nathan Sitter, said in court that he is ashamed of his actions and is “very remorseful.” He told the judge he “was not well.”

In March, Sitter pleaded guilty to one count of animal torture. Reportedly, he dunked the cat, named Mocha, under cold water and beat it with a closed fist. Though Sitter’s girlfriend took Mocha to the veterinarian, who documented numerous injuries, the animal died several hours later.

Prosecutors lobbied for Sitter to be imprisoned for four years because he left the cat to suffer. The man’s public defender, however, argues that he has been in counseling and had depression.

Regardless of the fact that Sitter is mentally unstable, the judge sentenced him only to six months in prison with probation. Understandably, animal rights activists are outraged. What is the difference between one life form and another, they argue?

Remember, it was Immanuel Kant who said:

“He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals.”

Is animal abuse an indication of what one might be capable of in the future? Is six months getting off too easy?

Comment your thoughts below and share this news!

This article (Man Gets 6 Months For Torturing Girlfriend’s Cat To Death) is free and open source. You have permission to republish this article under a Creative Commons license with attribution to the author and

To Top